The Maguad Family’s Agonizing Story: Trust, Betrayal, and the Weight of Justice

It began with good intentions. A family opened their home and hearts to a girl who needed care, believing that kindness could save her. Instead, their decision brought devastation so profound that the very walls of their home, once filled with joy, became stained with tragedy. This is the story of the Maguad family, a story retold in Toni Gonzaga’s “Toni Talks” and immortalized through an MMK (Maalaala Mo Kaya) episode—a story of trust betrayed, grief unending, and a justice system that continues to wound the survivors.

A Home Invaded by Darkness

When the Maguad family welcomed Janice (a pseudonym) into their home, they thought they were extending compassion. Their daughter Gwen had asked her parents to let Janice stay with them, and despite the mother’s instincts telling her otherwise, they agreed. It wasn’t formal adoption, but Gwen insisted that Janice needed their help.

From the start, unease lingered. Gwen’s mother admitted she felt resistance, a gut feeling she could not shake. Yet love for her daughter—and the natural inclination to care for someone in need—overruled hesitation. In hindsight, those instincts proved tragically accurate.

For Janice harbored envy. Observers noticed her fixation on Gwen, the way she compared herself, the way she seemed to desire Gwen’s place within the family. Over time, it became clear: she didn’t just want to be like Gwen. She wanted to be Gwen.

This obsession led to a horrifying plot, meticulously planned with an accomplice.

The Crime That Shattered a Family

On that fateful day, Gwen’s younger brother Boy Boy came home unexpectedly. He walked into the house while Janice’s accomplice was already inside. According to later confessions, the plan was only to kill Gwen. Boy Boy was never part of the design—he was “collateral damage,” a witness who could not be allowed to live.

The brutality of the crime defies comprehension. The father, Sir Cruz, recalls arriving at the scene. His prayers on the way home had been desperate: “Lord, please don’t let it happen. Just take everything—just not my children.” But when he entered, it was too late.

He wanted to hold his children one last time, but the violence done to their bodies was unbearable. Overcome with grief and horror, he could only sit and cry, then leave the house screaming for help.

His wife, upon being told, clung to denial: “Lord, please give them just a little bit of life.” But when she arrived, she too was barred from seeing them. Her husband begged her not to enter, not to witness the blood-soaked scene that would haunt him forever.

Their family home, the house they had lovingly built for their children, instantly became a prison of grief. Friends and relatives suggested leaving, but Sir Cruz resisted. “That’s where my children’s memories were formed,” he said. “No matter how painful, no matter how heavy, I will endure.”

The Shocking Discovery

For days, confusion and sorrow reigned. Then, evidence surfaced—IDs found hidden under Janice’s bed. One belonged to her boyfriend, the other to a young man who joined in the crime. Presented with the IDs, Janice admitted the truth: “There is really a way for me to get caught.”

Worse than the confession were her words to the police: “We won’t go to jail, right? Because we are still minors. Where will you take us?”

It was a chilling revelation of how broken the system is. These killers, inspired by loopholes in juvenile law, believed they could commit heinous acts without consequence. They were right—at least in the sense that the law shielded them from prison.

“Those killers were inspired by the law,” the parents explained. “Because they know that no matter how heinous their crime is, they will not go to jail. Because they are minors.”

For the grieving parents, this compounded the agony. Not only had they lost their children, but the perpetrators were protected by the very legal framework meant to safeguard society.

Grief That Never Ends

The Maguad parents describe grief not as a single event, but as an endless cycle. For two years after the tragedy, they lived in a fog, unable to escape the haunting memories. They tried traveling, distracting themselves, finding ways to forget—but the pain followed them everywhere.

“We realized that we are not happy, and we were always haunted by those memories of our children. It becomes more unbearable. After two years, our grieving truly began,” the mother admitted.

In moments of desperation, they turned to God. “I said, ‘Lord, I’m putting my hands up. Please give us an opportunity to understand the purpose.’”

When MMK called to feature their story, they hesitated but eventually agreed. They saw it as an answer to prayer, a chance to find meaning in the midst of suffering.

But even that was too heavy to bear. They managed to watch only the first part of the episode before turning it off. Reliving the crime on screen was too painful, reopening wounds that had barely begun to scar.

Faith as Their Only Anchor

The father confessed to Toni Gonzaga that his deepest struggle was resisting the urge for vengeance. “Can you let me have a moment with the ones who committed the crime? Even just for a while? I really want to crush them.”

But then, through tears, he added: “I’m just praying that I don’t sin. That I won’t turn into a criminal. That’s my only ace. That’s the only way to see each other again.”

His words reveal the impossible balance victims must hold: the raw human desire for justice—or even revenge—versus the spiritual commitment to forgiveness and hope.

For the Maguad parents, faith remains their only source of strength. They believe one day they will see their children again, and that hope is what sustains them.

Lessons in Trust, Law, and Society

This tragedy exposes several deep wounds—not just of one family, but of a society that allowed it to happen.

First, it is a warning about misplaced trust. The Maguads’ good intentions—opening their home to someone in need—were exploited by a person consumed with envy and resentment. Their story reminds us that even acts of compassion require discernment.

Second, it highlights the failures of juvenile justice. The perpetrators knew they could avoid real punishment because of their age. When laws embolden criminals instead of deterring them, they fail both victims and society.

Finally, it reveals the resilience of parents who, despite unimaginable loss, refuse to let hate consume them. Their ability to cling to faith, even while acknowledging the darkness in their hearts, is a testament to the strength of the human spirit.

Conclusion: A Family’s Enduring Cry

The Maguad family’s story is one of unimaginable pain. Their daughter Gwen, full of promise, and their son Boy Boy, innocent and unprepared, were robbed of life by someone they trusted. The betrayal came not from strangers, but from within their home.

Years later, the wounds remain raw. The parents live every day with grief, questions, and a justice system that seems to mock their suffering. Yet they endure—through faith, through prayer, through the belief that one day they will be reunited with their children.

In their story lies a haunting lesson for all: that evil can grow where we least expect it, that laws can fail the very people they are meant to protect, and that forgiveness, however impossible it feels, is the only path that keeps survivors from being consumed by the same darkness that destroyed their loved ones.

As the father said with quiet strength: “That’s my only ace. That’s the only way to see each other again.”

Full video: